三亿体育官网

Skip to Main Content
三亿体育官网

Sigmund and Hillary

October 13, 2016

This article is part of the 三亿体育官网 Election 2016 series.

三亿体育官网 business professor Minita Sanghvi has some insights into Hillary Clinton's presidential campaign. A scholar of the marketing of female politicians, Sanghvi says Clinton has a subtle Freudian advantage that could help her win the day: her candidacy is more palatable to many American voters because she鈥檚 following her husband.

freudSanghvi has written that "if Sigmund Freud were here watching the campaigns, he would predict her victory . . . not because of her expertise or popularity, but because of whose wife she is." She says the United States has a strong patriarchal culture, and "Americans worry about instituting a female leader because, if only subconsciously, they worry about what that would mean for the power and authority that reside in the social concept of maleness. As Freud might explain it, in our society women are considered passive and submissive while men are considered active wielders of agency. Women are the objects, to be desired and obtained and acted on, while men are the subjects or actors, the masters of their own destinies. Thus a woman coming to power and acting as a subject in her own right creates anxiety, especially in men concerned about their own power: if male authority loses its exclusivity, does that reduce its potency?" 

Many women in US politics came to power as the widows of senators, representatives, or governors; the first woman ever elected governor without a prior-office-holding husband was Connecticut鈥檚 Ella Grasso in 1975. Sanghvi has noted, "Electing a woman to follow in her man's footsteps, as Hillary may do in Bill's, is not only a tried and tested method; it also puts to rest any worries about emasculating the First Gentleman. It wouldn't take anything away from Bill Clinton, since he was already president. Or as Freud would say, if Hillary becomes a bearer of phallic power, it will derive from her husband's power." 

minita sanghvi
Prof. Minita Sanghvi

Sanghvi has argued that this is a reassuring if unspoken logic for many Americans, whose biases against women in politics are often subconscious鈥"which makes Freud's perspective particularly relevant," she says. "Several studies have shown that women politicians get more media coverage about their personal appearance, are addressed more informally, and are asked different questions鈥攁ll of which overtly or subtly undermines their perception as serious, substantive leaders. As Freud would point out, we may think our nation is based on fairness, yet 95 years after women got the right to vote, we haven鈥檛 managed to elect one female president or vice president, have had only 36 female governors, and rank 85th in the world for women's representation in government." 

Now, she concludes, "we have a female candidate who carries acceptable, husband-derived power, along with being competent and experienced in her own right."

 

Related News


Nigel+Smith+%E2%80%9919+holds+a+%22wing%22+up+to+his+mouth+during+the+%22Hot+Ones%22+challenge%2C+Austin+Somers+%E2%80%9925+can+be+seen+doing+the+same+to+the+left
Both alumni believe in giving back 鈥 and now they鈥檙e rallying the next generation of philanthropy at 三亿体育官网 through mentorship, generosity, and even a hot 鈥渨ing鈥 challenge.
Apr 1 2025

Rodrigo+Schneider+in+front+of+an+image+of+a+clock
A celebration of the liberal arts at 三亿体育官网, the symposium demonstrated how deeply creativity and humanistic inquiry are woven into the College鈥檚 academic fabric.
Mar 31 2025

A+member+of+the+Sphinx+Virtuosi+in+a+fuchsia+dress+plays+the+violin%2C+photo+credit+Scott+Jackson
The 20th annual String Festival will feature the Sphinx Virtuosi, a self-conducted chamber orchestra composed of 18 outstanding Black and Latino musicians, scheduled for Friday, April 4, through Sunday, April 6.
Mar 28 2025